A Father Returns to Tessa’s Life
After We CollidedTessa’s encounter with her estranged father reopens childhood questions about alcoholism and family, while the book leaves their relationship unresolved.
increasing
Bearing strength in each event
decreasing
A Buried Childhood

A Buried Childhood
A violent home
Tessa grows up witnessing her father’s drinking and his abuse of her mother before he leaves the family.
Memory kept at a distance
She has not seen him for years and has rarely examined what his absence means to her.
News of His Return

News of His Return
Tessa learns the truth
Noah tells Tessa that her father has moved back to Washington, a fact her mother had kept from her.
Choice reclaimed
Tessa resents that her mother decided on her behalf that he would not contact her. She wants the right to choose whether to meet him.
A Difficult Conversation

A Difficult Conversation
An argument with her mother
Tessa confronts Mrs. White about the news and is dismissed rather than comforted.
Old anger resurfaces
The encounter leaves Tessa distressed and thinking about the parent she has not seen, prompting her to seek comfort elsewhere.
Hardin Offers Shelter

Hardin Offers Shelter
A familiar refuge
Tessa calls Hardin and asks whether she can come back. He immediately welcomes her.
Comfort and complication
His response gives her a place to land, while reinforcing how closely her family distress has become entangled with her relationship.
The Street Encounter

The Street Encounter
Recognition in the snow
Tessa sees a disheveled man outside a tattoo shop and recognizes him as her father.
A new unresolved chapter
The recognition shocks her before either can speak meaningfully. The ending opens a family story that neither Tessa nor Hardin can control.
Before Tessa begins college
Christmas break
The day Tessa returns to her mother’s home
Minutes after Tessa leaves her mother’s house
Near the end of the book